Dear Hon Betty Amongi,

Africa Institute for Energy Governance (Afiego) noted with concern your attempts to fool Ugandans into thinking that government’s insistence on amending the Constitution to deprive citizens of their right to prior compensation in compulsory land acquisition exercises is good.

You said the proposed amendments, which have the support of the NRM caucus in parliament, are meant to curb dangerous speculative behaviour while offering Ugandans the benefits of pursuing development projects prior to compensating speculators who reject government compensation. You noted that Uganda is losing billions of shillings owing to speculators who reject low compensation.

You assured Ugandans that government arrives at compensation rates through a scientific and participatory process in which district land boards, in consultation with the people and the chief government valuer, set compensation.

Based on your narrative, the impression that compensation processes favour poor Ugandans was given. You gave examples of countries such as Kenya, Rwanda and Ethiopia where governments acquire people’s property before compensation and said Uganda was better than them.

We want to point out that you are propagating a wrong narrative. Compensation processes in Uganda do not favour the common man and you very well know that.

We are aware of this owing to our experience in working with communities affected by compulsory land acquisitions. Afiego is a public policy research and advocacy non-governmental organisation (NGO) dedicated to influencing energy policies to benefit the poor and vulnerable.

For the last ten years, we have defended the rights of local communities against poor compensation and land grabbers and we have witnessed untold suffering many communities affected by compulsory acquisition go through across the country.

Not only does compensation delay, sometimes over ten years, low compensation is also often given. Unfortunately for communities, the use of cut-off dates by the government does not allow the poor to negotiate.

They just accept whatever government gives to save their lives. Yes, some people are speculators, but majority of the citizens withstand the negative effects of cut-off dates. If we are looking for examples, we need not look further than here in Kampala.

I recently met an Entebbe-Expressway-affected person who told me that after being assessed in 2014, Unra recently returned to their home to confirm that, two years after they should have been compensated, they had not put up any new developments.

This family lives along Salama road, and as you can imagine, the value of their land has appreciated yet the value for 2016 will not be reflected in the final as their property was assessed in 2014.

This family’s experience mirrors that of nearly every household that has been affected by compulsory land acquisitions. Families affected by the Jinja-Kenya transmission line, Mbarara-Rwanda transmission line, the Hoima-Kaiso Tonya road, Karuma power project, the proposed oil refinery, etc, have similar stories.

Yet you say that government incurs interest owing to failure to pay project-affected persons using loans; it is these loans that result in loss of over Shs 96bn a year. Pray then, Madam Minister, if government has money to compensate people, why does it fail to pay even those who have accepted payment?

It needs to be noted that district land boards are dysfunctional owing to lack of training, money and appointment letters for recorders and Area Land Committee (ALC) members. Yet you say that government wants to protect poor customary landowners who are displaced by speculators who thereafter ask for high compensation and delay government projects.

This is suspect not least because despite repeated calls for certificates of customary ownership from people in Hoima and the oil region, your government has refused to issue these certificates but also because recorders and ALCs are not capacitated to work. They do not have appointment letters and get no salaries.

Madam Minister, you need to note that your government has failed or ignored the need to put regulations for the assessment and payment of compensation as required by section 20 of the 1965 Land Acquisition Act for over 50 years.

The absence of compensation regulations means that there is no formal framework that can help government and landowners to negotiate and determine what is timely/prompt, fair and adequate compensation as provided for under Article 26 of the Constitution. 

Government uses the gaps in the laws to dictate and impose unfair compensation values on affected persons and when people complain, the same government, using its majority in parliament, wants to use the proposed unjust laws to silence them. This is unfair and actions by government continue to cause untold suffering to communities.

Finally, you propose that for households or persons that reject low compensation, payments will be deposited in court. How will this proposal help the poor people such as those around Lake Albert to access justice when the nearest Magistrate’s court is 100km away while the High court is 200km to 300km away?

Based on the above, we reiterate that you should drop your proposed amendments including Clauses 3 and 4 which provide for “deposit[ing] in court or with any other competent authority the value of the property as evaluated by the chief government valuer” and “government take[ing] possession of the property where the government has deposited the evaluated compensation amount referred to in clause (3).”

The author is the chief executive officer of Afiego.