
Last week, we reflected upon the conundrum that loyalty presents – the precarious balance between being a ‘ride or die’ and Ubuntu – the greater good of “I am because we are”.
This conundrum is vividly illustrated in “My Sister, the Serial Killer”, a 2018 dark humuor novel by Nigerian author Oyinkan Braithwaite, about two sisters – Korede, the older, dutiful sister, and Ayoola, her beautiful and clueless younger sister, who also happens to have the inconvenient habit of killing her boyfriends.
Korede wrestles with her familial loyalty to Ayoola and her growing guilt over her sister’s growing pile of bodies. The novel opens with Ayoola calling her sister to help her dispose of a body (for what are big sisters for?); the manner in which Korede springs into action, methodical and unfazed, suggests this is not a first for the sisters.
Machiavellian philosophy suggests that loyalty becomes dangerous entanglement when it is blind rather than principled, thereby making a clear distinction between loyalty to the cause and loyalty to the individual.
Columnist and political theorist Yusuf Serunkuma’s interview with the head of the Uganda Government Media Centre, Alan Kasujja, on the November 3 The Observer podcast, invites us to reflect upon that distinction.
Kasujja shared some enlightening insights into his longstanding close friendship with the First Son and Chief of the Defence Forces, General Muhoozi Kainerugaba (MK). Kasujja revealed that he has known MK from their teenage days and that their friendship has evolved into a “covenant brotherhood sealed in blood”.
Kasujja, who also identified himself as a proud “hardcore” member of MK’s outfit, Patriotic League of Uganda (PLU), stated, “My relationship with him (MK) is not opportunistic… This is my elder brother…I stand ten toes with him.”
He stressed, “The man (MK) carries elephants on his head on a daily basis. That requires support…solidarity. When it comes down to loyalty, we go down together.”
Kasujja continued categorically, “I would never ever under any circumstances publicly disagree with anything that he says or does. I will walk away from the public office very happily before I can criticize the Chief of Defence Forces.”
Kasujja’s standing ten toes with his childhood friend is beautiful to behold – reminiscent of the fictional Korede. Meanwhile, for Korede, the bodies start rising to the surface of her conscience when her homicidal sister sets her seductive sights on Korede’s love interest, a handsome doctor – who unfortunately wants what he wants – the beautiful and inconveniently murderous Ayoola.
When her sister’s potential victim becomes a face that Korede desires to have and hold lovingly, hairline fractures spread through her loyalty. A Machiavellian critique of loyalty posits that loyalty is more insidious than outright betrayal because loyalty can be cloaked in good intentions.
Blind loyalty becomes a deadly cancer spreading from within. Thus, dear reader, the greatest danger isn’t outside enemies but the people within, your nearest and dearest, who choose obedience over honesty, those who keep you nicely ensconced in your gold-plated echo chamber, cheering you on as you rush recklessly like a boda boda into the oncoming traffic.
In October, a former army intelligence officer, Lt. Mabonga Herbert Matanda, stampeded onto our screens and news headlines with viral videos alleging illegal detention and torture within the army, including a viral video purportedly showing the disappeared activist Sam Mugumya as crippled and malnourished.
Mabonga has continued his assertions about abuse and corruption within the army, harshly condemning the leadership of the Chief of Defense Forces (CDF), General Muhoozi Kainerugaba.
The Uganda People’s Defence Forces (UPDF) prides itself in being a professional army, keen to make a clear distinction from the yesteryears of past regimes where national armies preyed violently upon the citizens in whose stead they held coercive force.
The UPDF summarily rubbished Mabonga’s claims without batting an eyelid. Regime die-hards accused Mabonga of betraying the trust of the mighty and noble UPDF, calling for him to be detained (hopefully not in the place Mabonga talked about).
For any professional army in the service of citizens, Mabonga’s claims should be quite alarming. In a 2022 Democracy in Africa article, ‘The Dialectics of Loyalty in African Politics: Rule of Law and Corruption,’ Professor Abu Bakarr Bah states that loyalty is problematic in much of African politics because of the discrepancy between rules and practices.
Bah argues that to overcome the entanglement of loyalty, loyalty must be tied to ethics, noting, “Loyalty, in the absence of ethics, simply leads to the problematic side of loyalty and less toward its virtues. Ethics is the foundation of laws and the basis of social harmony.”
He notes, “The constitutions of nearly all African countries draw upon the noble principles of democracy, human rights, peace, and progress. In addition, there are abundance of laws that prohibit corruption.
Upholding these laws require more than just a draconian government, which is often corrupt and selectively applies the law. Rather, it requires a citizenry that finds the right place to exercise loyalty, notably loyalty to the principles of the constitution and the laws prohibiting corruption — notably to the rule of law itself.”
Thus, when the UPDF brushes off Mabonga so effortlessly like a smooth criminal without calling for independent investigations into his claims, to whom is the Uganda People’s Defence Forces loyal?
One would hope that the answer is in their name. Therafa, if Ugandans are continually disappeared and tortured in illegal detention centres, and even the national human rights body, the emasculated Uganda Human Rights Commission, in several annual reports has documented state security agencies as the leading perpetrators of torture, why is the UPDF comfortably ignoring Mabonga’s irritating whistle?
The Machiavellian critique contends that unchecked loyalty doesn’t strengthen power, it isolates it. Blind loyalty protects leaders’ fragile egos while slowly destroying the very cause it claims to serve.
The tragedy of loyalty untethered from ethics is that it slowly transforms friends into accomplices, supporters into enablers, and institutions into shields for impunity.
If our loyalty or ‘patriotism’ requires us to abandon truth, justice, and the greater good, then we have wandered far from loyalty itself. Loyalty to a person asks, “Whose side are you on?”
Loyalty to principle asks, “What is the right thing to do?” One seeks belonging. The other demands courage. Dear reader, enjoy this quote from “My Sister, the Serial Killer”: “The most loving parents and relatives commit murder with smiles on their faces. They force us to destroy the person we really are: a subtle kind of murder.”
smugmountain@gmail.com
The writer is a tayaad muzzukulu.

