Log in
Free: The Observer Mobile App - Exclusive Content and Services

How some of our cultural ways promote corruption

Last week, I had a random chat with Prof Jude Ssempebwa, my cantankerous friend from Makerere University.

It started with an article by Prof Karim Hirji that I had forwarded to him, an impassioned critique of Prof Mahmood Mamdani’s earlier paper titled ‘The African University’.

Our chat wandered from one thing to another, but mainly around the deterioration of academic standards in many African universities in general and Uganda in particular. We both agreed that, whereas they are expected to be the societal pinnacle of wisdom, universities are no exception to the general institutional decay that we witness outside university walls.

A few words ahead, we were at the issue of staffing, especially wondering how many people with no disposition to research and writing get into academic positions with the effect that in most of our universities it is only a thin percentage of ‘academics’ that are productive in research.

Some can even hardly write a well-argued essay, starting from grammar! For many, the norm is to teach and mark. Of course, many structural problems bedevil our universities today, sometimes making it difficult even for those that wish to research to do so.

Nevertheless, this doesn’t generally explain the paucity of our contribution to knowledge. Yet, still, the problematic recruitment procedures that we cited in universities are as well symptomatic of what happens in most of our institutions, both public and private.

This is how we got to the factor of culture as one of the contributors to this malaise. This is not a general appraisal of African cultures in suggestion of their inappropriateness; rather, it is an attempt to explain how some of its aspects may promote inappropriate practices in public life.

Most literature on African cultural philosophy and anthropology particularly points out a communitarian outlook as one of the key elements of African traditional societies. Society tends to take a more privileged position than the individual.

This is most prominently captured in John Mbiti’s famous coinage: ‘I am because we are.’ Some scholars have argued, though, that this is a feature of all ‘primitive’ societies, not only Africa - an interesting debate for another day.

Our society is a wide web of interconnections and allegiances layered from the nuclear family, extended family, clan, family friends, village-mates, ‘tribesmen’, religion-mates and so on. This network serves several social roles, such as buffering orphans, collective upbringing of children, promoting care for the well-being of each other, etc.

However, in here as well lies the root to many tendencies deemed corrupt in the public domain, stretching beyond our families, villages, and ‘tribes’.

In an article titled ‘Status to contract society: Africa’s integrity crisis’ (2008), Prof Edward Wamala from Makerere’s department of Philosophy observes that in such settings, quite often when we get a job, our extended family, village-mates, and tribes-mates celebrate with us.

By extension, they have also acquired a job, either through handouts from you or through job connections to where you have gained influence. This becomes worse in poor communities where the person acquiring a job could be either the only one or among the very few that have made it, with the entire clan or village now placing their hopes in him/her for jobs, fees, healthcare, food, upkeep, building houses, bills for weddings, introductions, funerals, etc.

The Baganda say, ‘akuwa obwami aba akuwadde kulya’ (whoever appoints you a chief gives you ‘eating’), but also that ‘ono alya, n’ono alya, y’emmere ewooma’ (food is delicious when others are eating too).

So, one has a long line of immediate others to eat with. Eating alone has terrible community consequences, including not being voted again or being bewitched, hated, etc... And, as Wamala notes, ‘the public is after all an alien entity.’ It is somehow okay to ‘steal’ from the impersonal public.

That is partly why a community will mobilise to demand for the release of their ‘son’ or ‘daughter’ who is implicated in corruption scandals. P.L.O. Lumumba puts it thus: ‘he is a thief, but he is our thief.’

When one gets a job somewhere where it’s imagined or understood that they command some powers of recruitment, the next day they start receiving visitors and calls pleading for some job for ‘our son’ – who may not have any relevant qualifications.

With the desire to help a relative/village-mate but also not to seem unhelpful (mean), one starts finding ways of ‘fixing’ them somewhere.

An uncle’s son, a friend’s daughter, a neighbour’s brother, an in- law, a cousin, and so on. It’s worse where institutional recruitment procedures are easily abused with no negative consequences. Sometimes such window entrants may happen to be competent, but many times not the most competent.

Just a matter of time, with the simmering nepotism and tribalism, and the organisation starts choking on incompetence as one person after the other tries to fix in their own too. Before you know it, the office goes vernacular – everyone literally feeling ‘at home.’

Why do many communities demand for ‘their own’ to be appointed into certain positions? Sometimes it is simply about feeling included, but many times it relates to joining the dining table by proxy, re-echoing Michela Wrong’s book title ‘It’s Our Turn to Eat.’

It is a conduit through which they hope to access state resources. Little wonder that our members of parliament keep demanding for more and more emoluments, with loans too.

For, on top of their own luxuries, they also have to fundraise for village markets, funerals, mosques, churches, weddings, introduction ceremonies, graduation parties, and so on. They are as well invited to officiate at launches of village SAccos and all sorts of associations, where they must contribute.

Without a commitment to creating strong institutional checks, corruption is bound to take deeper roots in societies like ours.

jsssentongo@gmail.com

The author works with the Center for African Studies at Uganda Martyrs University, Nkozi.

Comments

+3 #1 PaLugore 2018-09-26 09:58
This is typically what obtains at Makerere University, where it has been in existence for long.

At first it was dominated by the Ganda (no offence) but is now slowly changing to Westerner/Banyarwanda.

There are also students' organizations that bring together only members from particular tribe or region. This is retrogression not befitting an academic institution like Makerere to say the least.
Report to administrator
+2 #2 ejakait engoraton 2018-09-26 14:34
Quoting PaLugore:
This is typically what obtains at Makerere University, where it has been in existence for long.

At first it was dominated by the Ganda (no offence) but is now slowly changing to Westerner/Banyarwanda.

There are also students' organizations that bring together only members from particular tribe or region. This is retrogression not befitting an academic institution like Makerere to say the least.


There is nothing wrong with people coming together(aggregation) where they share a common interest as long as it is not at the expense of others, and as long as it is not for subversion of society.

When people come together because they share the same culture, language, religion, it is the same as engineers , accountants coming together, just like you coming together with your family members to the exclusion of others.

Doctors when they hold their meeting for instance can not invite along butchers.
Think positive/negative discrimination
Report to administrator
+1 #3 Wooden K. 2018-09-26 16:08
Nkulamusizza Dokita Satire . Webale gyonna !

Time has come for you learned guys to sit down somewhere and redfine "corruption". At least , you can contextualize the damn word .

So far , most people thought that corruption only happens when money changes hands ( when it shouldn`t).

But after the dead-body cash bonanza c/o Undertaker Kusasira , paying for a dead body instead delivering justice , we must adjust our original thinking .

SO , instead of checking corruption , you should teach people how to perfect it.

PS ; I was hoping for a cartoon about "daughters guarding their wealth " and then comes in Ensi Egula Mirambo Kusasira , the cash , the Hajis and their murdred son`s widows.

All of a sudden one can become rich by having one of their sons shot dead.

No no , if you are not corrupt , you are not smart .
Report to administrator
+1 #4 juwait kali 2018-09-26 16:10
What do you expect when nollywood shows people paying for an essay and the ministry concerned does nothing.

Kids see those miss deeds and believe it's normal those movies have to be censored.
Report to administrator
+3 #5 Jama 2018-09-28 02:36
To clean all this garbage, like nepotism ,tribalism and corruption which are littering all our institutions.

It will require a leadership with extraordinary conscience, surrounded by individuals who are ready to think and act beyond their community when it means serving the national interest.
Report to administrator
+1 #6 Akot 2018-09-28 16:51
Briliant article that explains Africa downhill! It's up to Africans to have 1 common language in Education so that chidren grow up as 1 fighting common destiny to build the kind of country they want knowing English is what their children need!

French realised without common language & National Education for All, there could not be nation building, development!

French have added more hours for English in their school curriculum as they too, want to be part of today world!

Ugandans MUST adopt English as National Langage & NOW as this is as important as throwing Musevnei out!

Those of us with blood from +1 tribe know English gave us chance to have jobs, talk with relatives without having to learning local languages that would have locked us further in poverty!

Besides, English gives Ugandans chance to even travel, work, talk to one another, go to school any where in the country!
Report to administrator
-1 #7 Akot 2018-09-28 17:37
DR JIMMY SPIRE SSENTONGO,

Why have Ugandans allowed, still allow Museveni to destroy them & their country to an extent the demon believes it's his brith right to do so?

Yet, even when Ugandans don't want to Reform the Republic, after their UNITY throws Museveni out, our people will just go for tribal states & make their tribal lands "independent countries" free from Museveni & free form one another!

Why maintain the trialistic system when tribes have no control over their land riches?

Why is Museveni who has no tribal land in Uganda the one who controls our land riches, taxes...?

Our people have no say in what goes on in the country, yet still naively believe is theirs, when it's not any more!

What is wrong with Ugandans?
Report to administrator
0 #8 JOHN WANDA 2018-10-01 21:59
I disagree. Communities build and sustain the individual, and the individual benefits as much from the community when he/she gets a good job as the community from him (read her).

They build and maintain the road for his car, push it when it gets stuck, provide labor when he/she wants to build, supply house boys and house girls to serve him, and give him and his property security.

They ask from him/her financial support because government and other mechanisms have failed them.

But they don't demand impossibles, and never eject or reject, a clansman who has failed to provide for them. They embrace him/her just the same.
Report to administrator
0 #9 Odessa Sekitte 2018-10-01 23:05
Seems like all the universal evils, the dark & destructive forces have converged in Uganda to dismantle any semblance of civility.

Cultural norms & decorum have been decimated. Some people will only love you as much as they can use you.

Their loyalty ends when the benefits stop.

The amount of toxicity among fellow citizens is unfathomable. “Earth provides enough to satisfy every man's needs, but not every man's greed.”
― Mahatma Gandhi
Report to administrator

Comments are now closed for this entry

Bunga Bet