Log in

Museveni sends Justice Bbosa to the ICC, a court he so loathes!

One of Uganda’s best judges, Solome Balungi Bbosa, has landed at the Hague-based International Criminal Court (ICC).

Strangely, although President Museveni is a vociferous critic of the ICC, it is understood that he assigned Attorney General William Byaruhanga and Uganda’s permanent representative at the UN, Adonia Ayebare, to lobby and ensure that she gets that posting.

The irony is that President Museveni once contemplated pulling Uganda out of ICC. Reason? The court targets African criminals and is lenient on those from Europe and America.

The president’s disapproval was particularly noticeable in 2016 when he defied ICC orders to arrest and surrender Sudan president Omar al-Bashir.

The ICC issued arrest warrants for Bashir in 2009 and 2010, accusing him of masterminding genocide and crimes against humanity during the campaigns to quell revolts in the Darfur region of Sudan.

As a signatory to the Rome Statute which established ICC, Uganda is required to act on its arrest warrants. But in 2016, Bashir attended President Museveni’s swearing-in ceremony and he flew out untouched.

The ICC is complementary to national jurisdictions, meaning that in cases where national courts could not try crimes under the statutes, the accused could be referred to it.

And this is captured in the preamble of the Rome Statute: “affirming that the most serious crimes of concern to the international community as a whole must not go unpunished and that their effective prosecution must be ensured by taking measures at national level and by enhancing international cooperation.”

Since this international court does not have a police force, it relies on the cooperation of the state parties to enforce its orders.

After the 2016 inauguration ceremony, Museveni explained that he could not invite Bashir and then later arrest and surrender him to ICC.

“That is very un-African. It is uhuni (buyaye). We don’t treat visitors like that,” he said.

And again this year, President Bashir came back to Uganda and his host drove him around his farm in Kisozi as the two heads of state smiled and chatted away.

It is only Botswana and Malawi that threatened Bashir with arrests. In June 2015, South Africa, another state party to the Rome Statute, was served with a request to help ICC arrest Bashir.

But the writing was on the wall that they were not willing to help the moment they allowed him on South African soil and accorded him all the immunities enjoyed by foreign dignitaries.

In international law, the doctrine of sovereign or diplomatic immunity entitles certain holders of high-ranking offices such as that of a president to enjoy immunities from jurisdiction in other states, both civil and criminal.

That means that national courts are unable to try a high official of another state who is suspected of committing crimes, as this would constitute a violation of state sovereignty.

This is derived from the United Nations Charter which enunciates the principle of the sovereign equality of all member states, whereby a state is not permitted to interfere in affairs that are within the domestic jurisdiction of another state.

Sovereign immunity covers both heads of state and the state itself. Personal immunity only extends to incumbent heads of state. And indeed, Bashir is a sitting president.

According to article 27 (irrelevance of official capacity) of the Rome Statute, Bashir’s official capacity as a sitting head of state does not exclude his criminal responsibility, neither does it grant him immunity against prosecution before the ICC. 

The article states: “This statute shall apply equally to all persons without any distinction based on official capacity. In particular, official capacity as a head of state or government, a member of a government or parliament, an elected representative or a government official shall in no case exempt a person from criminal responsibility under this Statute...”

Article 27 (2) adds: “Imunities or special procedural rules which may attach to the official capacity of a person, whether under national or international law, shall not bar the Court from exercising its jurisdiction over such a person.”

The good intentions of the ICC to fight impunity of dictators have been defeated by the very signatories to the Rome Statute.

There is apprehended bias. African leaders who were very enthusiastic when signing this law have lost vigour partly because many of them thought the law would only catch their opponents. Now it turns out that sitting presidents are subjects to ICC’s jurisdiction.

So, this is the milieu in which Justice Bbosa will operate. She is representing a country opposed to the conduct of ICC!

While her role is to dispense justice, she could as well be deployed to change the negative attitudes prevailing back home. Good luck, my lord!

The author is the business development director at Observer Media Limited.

Comments

0 #1 Akot 2017-12-13 15:25
Museveni is going to end up advising the entire world how to rule without opposition!

Have Ugandans not accepted his rule & go on in peace, even debating their belonging to their country, while opposition leaders only come out to fight internal leadership & have left museveni to do as he wishes?

Ugandans have become so perfect in maintaining the tribalistic system & are making sure it remains that way!

If museveni is a gift for Ugandans to ensure they stay tribaly divided but at peace, why would the rest of the world not go along?

Uganda is not nuclear threat as N.Koran is & as Ugandans go along, why should the outside world not do the same, more so, it's up to Ugandans to bring change, if they want it & it appears they don'!
Report to administrator
+1 #2 Gold Ruyondo 2017-12-15 20:52
So that when he gets there ,there is one of his,very strategic,isn't it ?
Report to administrator
+1 #3 kelem 2017-12-19 08:02
What do you expect of a confused old man!!
Report to administrator
-1 #4 Akot 2017-12-19 20:14
Gold Ruyondo, agreed.

More so, Ugandans are at peace with museveni & Acholi tribal leader has endorsed him, ignoring poverty in Achol & destruction caused for 30 years by museveni!

All museveni has to do to get USA-Europe-UN-ICC... on his side openly now is: Reform the Republic of Uganda to abolish tribalism by getting rid of posts of tribal leaders!

This will make museveni, the worst tribalist-worse dictator ever, accepted while Ugandans will be told off for being tribalists!

Museni's U turn from tribalist dictator & will be forgiven, including destroying Uganda & its people! After all the outside world needs Uganda natural resources & it's a peaceful country for diplomats, right?

Even when Ugandans will be NOTHING & Rwandese in control, this will be good for the outside world!
Report to administrator
+1 #5 Akot 2017-12-19 20:21
kelem, understood, yet,

Museveni is going to get worse as he grows older & does not accept it!

This is why he is now in a hurry to conclude conquest of territory & is so so kind to Acholi & wants them on his side!

Is this what tribes that United against Acholi in 1986 to bring in museveni want?

Museveni plays about & uses with every body & will even end up getting ICC on his side!

Don't we see U.Kenyatta who does the right things is all alone, abandoned by bodies crying out they want peace for all, yet treat Kenyatta as the trouble causer while demon Odinga is applauded each time he sets fire in Kenya after returning from holidays from USA?

Ugandans are in troubled waters & they alone can do what it takes to get out or musevnei will do the right things now & the outside world will just go along with him!
Report to administrator

Comments are now closed for this entry

betPawa