Log in

Kyagulanyi petition: Mabirizi accuses chief justice of Museveni bias

CJ Alfonse Owiny-Dollo arrives for the pre-hearing session of Kyagulanyi's election petition

CJ Alfonse Owiny-Dollo arrives for the pre-hearing session of Kyagulanyi's election petition

Controversial city lawyer, Male Mabirizi has petitioned the chief justice Alfonse Owiny-Dollo asking him to excuse himself from the election petition filed by National Unity Platform president Robert Kyagulanyi aka Bobi Wine. 

Kyagulanyi, has listed over 26 grounds before the court to invalidate incumbent President Yoweri Museveni's January 14 election victory, arguing that it was not conducted in accordance with the principles laid down in the laws governing elections such as the constitution, the Presidential Elections Act and the Electoral Commission Act. He cites intimidation of voters, heavy security deployment during the election, and arrest of his agents among other factors for the petition. 

Chief justice Owiny-Dollo is the lead judge on the panel of nine justices set to hear Kyagulanyi's petition. But now Mabirizi says Owiny-Dollo's earlier association and relationship as Museveni's lawyer and the fact that he has held discussions with the same respondent after Kyagulanyi's petition had been filed makes his presence on the Supreme court panel "not only be illegal but also unacceptable and against the fairness principle since justice must not only be done but must also be seen to be done.”

The other justices on the panel besides Owiny-Dollo are Dr Esther Kisaakye Kitimbo, Stella Arach-Amoko, Rubby Aweri Opio, Faith Essy Mwondha, Paul Kahaibale Mugamba, Ezekiel Muhanguzi, Percy Night Tuhaise, and Mike Chibita. They are expected to determine the case on March 18.

Mabirizi says he has information that the chief justice was a lawyer representing Museveni in the 2006 election petition when the president was accused of similar election misconduct by then opposition Forum for Democratic Change presidential candidate Dr Kizza Besigye.

Mabirizi says that he's also informed that Owiny-Dollo recently met Museveni at State House soon after Kyagulanyi had filed his petition. He says Owiny-Dollo's participation in the case erodes the confidence not only in him but the entire judiciary because "judgment must be rooted in confidence and confidence is destroyed when right-minded people go away thinking the judge was biased."

Mabirizi refers to Legal Notice No.7 of 2019 which states that a judicial officer shall refrain from participating in any proceedings in which the impartiality of the judicial officer may reasonably be questioned.

Section one of the same notice further requires recusal "where a judicial officer has background information or experience such as the judicial officer's prior work as a lawyer."

Mabirizi says that if the chief justice continues sitting on the panel, he will no doubt be contravening the constitutional principles laid down under Article 28(1) which talks about right to fair hearing and article 44(C) which prohibits derogation from the enjoyment of particular human rights which include right to fair hearing.

He also adds Article 126 which provides for judicial power which is derived from the people and should be exercised by the courts in the name of the people and in conformity with law and with the values, norms and aspirations of the people, and lastly Article 128 which provides for the independence of the judiciary and that no authority shall interfere with courts or judicial officers in the exercise of their judicial function.

Mabirizi argues that the constitution "was made after several human sacrifices of our dear predecessors and brothers in the name of fairness as indicated in the preamble of the constitution and you will have abdicated your judicial oath."  

Mabirizi's petition was received by the office of the chief justice on Friday 12th 2021 and a response is yet to be given.

Comments   

+9 #1 Rwatooro 2021-02-14 05:24
Thank you Mr. Male Mabiriizi! You have identified the big issue in what they are trying to with M7.

Owiny-Dollo is a highly corrupt man; you can even tell right after the Kyagulanyi team filed the case, he rushed to State House. What did he go to do in Statehouse after filing the case?

Did he go for consultation and pickup the bribe? M7 is known for giving up bribes on certain issues. Why did M7 meet them immediately after Kyagulanyi filed the case?

Another judge is Michael Chib, a highly corrupt man. A lot is going on about Michael Chib on social media about a murder case he manipulated. They should both step down!
Quote | Report to administrator
+7 #2 Lysol 2021-02-14 05:35
One child-hood friend of Owiny-Dollo who died mysteriously, in exile because of Museveni, would turn in his own grave.

They both shared the same first name.
Quote | Report to administrator
+8 #3 Byamukama Patrick 2021-02-14 08:13
If fact with OWINY-DOLLO, we cannot expect justice in this case.
Quote | Report to administrator
+7 #4 Stewart 2021-02-14 13:41
And Male Mabirizi never fails, he has been steadfast in exposing these fallacies but people hardly paid attention, he is right on the spot. Thanks
Quote | Report to administrator
+7 #5 Nabankema 2021-02-14 14:33
Bravo Male, even Owiny-Dollo is so corrupt even to the to the extent of giving instructions that the hearing will be in writing from both side, only 30 minutes speech from the Lawyers?

Kyagulanyi Election filling Against Museveni has to be a public hearing. Because it is for the People of Ugandans who struggled to Vote that day in spite all the torturing they went through! People are going to speak up , if Justice dept. doesn’t do their job!
Quote | Report to administrator
+7 #6 Manny 2021-02-14 15:23
Even in a highly democratised country like America, if it ever happens that one president was to appoint all the 9 justices of the supreme court like museveni has over the decades in Uganda, democracy would cease to exist.

All those wigged men and women that you see on TV showing the posture of impartiality have deep rooted ties to M7.

Almost all of them owe their careers to museveni. For some, he even gave juicy jobs to their spouses. It surely would take a lot for them to "betray" him.
Quote | Report to administrator
+4 #7 Lakwena 2021-02-15 08:46
In other words, Owiny Dollo has an impeachable character, which should not be the case for any judge worth the title.

A week ago when I heard Owiny Dolloo pandering and groveling before Gen Tibuhaburwa, over the promised improved budget allocation to the Judiciary, my heart sunk. And I am sure God wept over the future of Uganda.

For what does it benefits a man he gains the whole world but loses his soul?
Quote | Report to administrator
+1 #8 Kirya 2021-02-15 18:29
The chief justice will face the brutal uprising when he manipulates the case.

Let them know that the whole panel of judges will be the soft targets We are dick and tired of m7 and his crap.
Quote | Report to administrator